Every Research Article, Review Article, Short Communication, Data Article and Technical Note published in Sustainable EcoSciences has been peer reviewed by independent experts. This page describes how manuscripts are handled from submission to decision.
Review model
The journal currently operates single-blind peer review.
- Single-blind: reviewers know the identity of the authors; the authors do not know the identity of the reviewers.
- Double-blind: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other. Authors submit an anonymized manuscript.
- Open: authors and reviewers know each other's identities.
Reviewer reports are shared with authors anonymously, as "Reviewer 1", "Reviewer 2" and so on. Comments that reviewers address confidentially to the editor are never shared.
Editorial process
- Technical check. The editorial office checks that the submission is complete, follows the Guide for Authors and complies with the journal's policies. Incomplete submissions are returned to the authors.
- Editorial assessment. The Editor-in-Chief or a handling editor assesses the manuscript's fit with the scope, originality, significance and quality. Manuscripts that are out of scope or clearly unsuitable are declined without external review, so that authors can submit elsewhere without delay.
- Peer review. The handling editor invites independent reviewers with expertise in the subject. Research Articles normally receive at least two reports. Reviewers are asked to submit their report within 14 days.
- Decision. The handling editor considers the reports and the manuscript and makes a decision: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject. The decision letter and the reviewers' comments are sent to the corresponding author.
- Revision. Authors revise the manuscript and submit a point-by-point response to every comment, together with a version showing the changes. The decision letter states the deadline, normally 30 days for minor revisions and 60 days for major revisions. Extensions can be requested.
- Further rounds. The editor may decide on a revised manuscript directly or send it to the same or new reviewers. Several rounds of revision are possible. Manuscripts that do not adequately address major concerns after revision may be rejected.
- Acceptance and production. Accepted manuscripts are copy-edited and typeset. The corresponding author approves the proof before publication.
Role of the editors
The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the editorial policy and content of the journal. Handling editors are active researchers in the field who manage the review of individual manuscripts and make decisions on them. The editors' names and affiliations are listed on the Editorial Board page.
Selection of reviewers
Editors select reviewers for their expertise and independence. Reviewers must declare any competing interest and decline if they cannot assess the manuscript impartially. Authors may suggest and oppose reviewers at submission. Editors consider these suggestions but are not bound by them, and never rely on author-suggested reviewers alone.
Editorial independence
Decisions are based only on the scientific quality, originality, significance and relevance of the work. They are not influenced by the authors' nationality, ethnicity, gender, institution, political or religious beliefs, by commercial considerations, or by whether an article processing charge is paid or waived.
Submissions from editors and board members
Manuscripts submitted by an editor or editorial board member are handled by another editor with no conflict of interest. The submitting editor has no access to the review of their own manuscript, and the same standards apply as for every other submission.
Special issues
Special issues follow the same peer-review standards as regular submissions. Guest editors cannot handle manuscripts on which they are authors or have a conflict of interest; such manuscripts are handled by a member of the editorial board. The Editor-in-Chief approves every decision in a special issue.
Appeals
Authors who believe a decision was based on a factual error or a misunderstanding of their work may appeal by writing to info@sustainableecosciences.com within 30 days of the decision. Give the manuscript number and explain in detail why the decision should be reconsidered. Appeals are assessed by an editor not involved in the original decision, who may seek further review. The outcome of an appeal is final.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts under review are confidential. Editors and reviewers must not share them or use their content before publication.
