Guidelines

Reviewer Guidelines

Last updated 5 Oct 2026

Reviewers make an essential contribution to the quality of Sustainable EcoSciences. These guidelines describe what the journal expects from reviewers and how to prepare a report that helps both the editor and the authors.

Responding to an invitation

  • Expertise. Accept only if you can assess the manuscript competently. If you are qualified to judge only part of it, accept and tell the editor which part you assessed.
  • Competing interests. Decline if you have a competing interest: recent collaboration or co-authorship with the authors, the same institution, a personal relationship, a financial interest, or a competing project.
  • Time. Reviewers are normally asked to submit their report within 14 days. If you need more time, tell the editor when you accept.

Please respond to invitations promptly, even if you decline. Suggesting an alternative reviewer is very helpful.

Confidentiality

Treat the manuscript and all related material as confidential. Do not share it, discuss it with others or use its content before publication. If you wish to involve a colleague or student in the review, ask the editor first and name them in your confidential comments. Do not contact the authors.

Generative AI

Do not upload the manuscript or any part of it, or your report, to generative AI tools. This breaches the confidentiality of the authors' work. The scientific assessment must be your own.

What to assess

  • Scope and significance: does the work fit the journal and advance knowledge in its field?
  • Originality: is the work new, and is its novelty stated clearly?
  • Study design and methods: are the sampling design, field and laboratory methods, quality control, models and statistical analyses appropriate and described in enough detail to be reproduced?
  • Data: are the data adequate to support the conclusions, are uncertainties quantified, and are the data available as stated in the data availability statement?
  • Results and conclusions: do the results support the conclusions, and are limitations and alternative explanations discussed?
  • Literature: is relevant previous work cited fairly, including studies that reach different conclusions?
  • Presentation: are the text, figures, maps and tables clear and accurate, and is the abstract a fair summary?
  • Ethics: are there concerns about plagiarism, data integrity, duplicate publication, missing permits or approvals?

Structure of the report

  1. Summary. Summarise the manuscript and its main contribution in a few sentences, in your own words.
  2. Major comments. Issues that affect the validity of the results or conclusions, with clear explanations and, where possible, suggestions for addressing them.
  3. Minor comments. Points of clarity, presentation and wording, with line numbers.

Be specific, constructive and courteous. Comment on the work, not on the authors. Do not ask authors to cite your own work unless it is clearly relevant. Under double-blind review, avoid comments that would reveal your identity. You may attach an annotated file and indicate whether the editor may share it with the authors.

Recommendation

  • Accept: the manuscript can be published as it is.
  • Minor revision: small changes are needed; the editor may check them without further review.
  • Major revision: substantial changes are needed, and the revised manuscript should be reviewed again.
  • Reject: the work has fundamental flaws, offers insufficient advance, or does not fit the journal.

The editor makes the final decision, weighing all reports. Use the confidential comments to the editor for any remarks you do not want shared with the authors, but make sure your report to the authors is consistent with your recommendation.

Reviewing a revised manuscript

When you assess a revision, you will see the authors' point-by-point response, the revised files and your earlier report. Check whether each of your comments has been addressed adequately. Raise new issues only if they are important or were introduced by the revision.

Ethical concerns

If you suspect plagiarism, fabricated or manipulated data or images, duplicate submission, or research carried out without the required approvals or permits, explain your concern to the editor in the confidential comments. Do not investigate further or contact the authors yourself. The editors will handle the matter following COPE guidance.

Recognition

The journal is grateful for the time and expertise reviewers contribute. On request, the editorial office will confirm your reviewing activity for your institution or for services that record peer-review contributions.