Sustainable EcoSciences is committed to the integrity of the scholarly record. The journal follows the guidance and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and expects authors, reviewers and editors to meet the standards below.
Duties of authors
Originality and plagiarism
Authors must submit original work and must cite the work of others accurately. Plagiarism in any form, including copying text, data, figures or ideas without attribution, and reusing substantial parts of one's own published work without citation, is unacceptable. Submissions may be checked with similarity-detection software.
Multiple, redundant or concurrent publication
Authors must not submit the same research to more than one journal at a time, or publish manuscripts that describe essentially the same research in more than one place. Splitting a single study into several minimal publications is discouraged; related publications must be cited and disclosed to the editor.
Data and image integrity
Fabrication, falsification or selective reporting of data, including model outputs, is research misconduct. Images, maps and figures must not be manipulated in ways that misrepresent the data. Authors should keep their raw data and provide it to the editors on request during review or after publication.
Authorship
All authors must meet the journal's authorship criteria, approve the final manuscript and agree to its submission. Everyone who meets the criteria must be included. Guest, gift and ghost authorship are not acceptable.
Competing interests and funding
Authors must disclose all financial and non-financial interests that could be seen to influence their work, and all sources of funding.
Ethical approvals, permits and samples
Research involving human participants or animals must have the required ethical approvals. Fieldwork, sampling and the transport of samples must comply with the laws and permits of the countries concerned, including the rules for protected areas and species and, where applicable, the Nagoya Protocol on access to genetic resources. Researchers working with local and Indigenous communities should respect their rights over data and knowledge.
Citation practices
Cite the sources that informed the work. Excessive self-citation, citation arrangements between authors or journals, and citations requested without scientific justification are not acceptable.
Generative AI
Use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools in preparing a manuscript must be declared. AI tools cannot be authors, and authors are fully responsible for the content of their work.
Fundamental errors
Authors who discover a significant error in their submitted or published work must inform the editor promptly and cooperate in correcting or retracting it.
Duties of reviewers
- Assess manuscripts objectively and provide constructive reports in a timely manner.
- Keep manuscripts confidential and do not use unpublished information for their own research.
- Declare competing interests and decline invitations where these exist.
- Do not upload manuscripts to generative AI tools or other external services.
- Alert the editor to any suspected misconduct.
Duties of editors
- Evaluate manuscripts solely on their scientific merit and relevance, without regard to the authors' personal characteristics or affiliations.
- Keep information about submitted manuscripts confidential and protect the anonymity of reviewers.
- Declare competing interests and hand over manuscripts where these exist.
- Ensure that the peer review is fair, unbiased and timely.
- Respond to concerns about misconduct and publish corrections, retractions or expressions of concern when needed.
Handling suspected misconduct
Concerns about a submitted or published article can be raised confidentially with the editorial office at info@sustainableecosciences.com. The journal follows COPE guidance in every case. The authors are given an opportunity to respond. Depending on the outcome, the journal may reject the manuscript, publish a correction or an expression of concern, retract the article, or inform the authors' institutions or funders.
Corrections, retractions and expressions of concern
- Correction: published when an error affects part of an article but not its main findings.
- Expression of concern: published when there are serious concerns about an article and an investigation is ongoing or inconclusive.
- Retraction: published when the findings are unreliable because of misconduct or major error, or in cases of plagiarism, redundant publication or unethical research. Retracted articles remain online and are clearly marked, to preserve the scholarly record.
Every notice is linked to the original article and shown on its page.
Complaints and appeals
Complaints about the journal's processes can be sent to info@sustainableecosciences.com. They are acknowledged and handled by an editor not involved in the matter concerned. Appeals against editorial decisions follow the procedure in the Peer Review Policy.
